19-ab-test-setup — independently scanned and version-tracked by SaferSkills.
SaferSkills independently audited 19-ab-test-setup (Agent Skill) and scored it 100/100 (green). The audit ran 55 deterministic rules across Security, Supply Chain, Maintenance, Transparency, and Community; it found 0 high-severity and 0 lower-severity findings. The full rule-by-rule trace and per-finding evidence are below. Free, methodology-open.
Findings & checks · 0 flagged
Every scanned point with the score it earned and what moved between them.
First recorded scan — no prior version to compare against.
The primary manifest — the file an agent reads to learn what this artifact does.
Doc .agents/product-marketing-context.md neu co.
Quy tac cot loi. Neu test 2 bien cung luc → khong biet bien nao tac dong.
Mot ngoai le duy nhat — test hook video. Hook va doan on-ramp 3-15s ngay sau no la mot cap khong tach roi: doi hook ma bung nguyen than video cu se lam dut mach va hold rate sup, khien ket qua vo nghia. Khi test hook, viet lai on-ramp cho khop tung hook va ghi bien test la "hook + on-ramp". Chi tiet: references/hook-formulas-vn.md.
Format: "Neu lam [X], metric [Y] se tang [Z%]"
Khong duoc dung test som.
Test tung tuan tron (khong 3 ngay, khong 10 ngay) — khach mua hanh vi khac nhau cac ngay.
Khong check ket qua moi gio. Dung ket qua cho den khi het thoi han + du sample.
Chi tin khi p-value < 0.05. Neu khong: ngau nhien, khong phai do bien cua ban.
Ghi lai:
→ De sau nay ban khong test lai cai da test.
Khong muon tinh tay, hoac dang bi ket khong biet test gi tiep: doc references/sample-size-va-y-tuong-test.md — co bang tra sample size da tinh san, loi thoat khi traffic qua thap, va ngan hang 70+ y tuong test kem gia thuyet theo tung be mat.Sample size/variant =
16 × p × (1-p) / MDE²
Trong do:
p = Baseline conversion rate hien tai (vi du 0.02 = 2%)
MDE = Minimum Detectable Effect (muc do thay doi toi thieu ban muon phat hien, vi du 0.2 = 20% tang)Landing page hien co conv rate 3%, muon phat hien thay doi 20%+:
=> Can 25,866 visit total, neu 500 visit/ngay → 52 ngay.
Landing page hien conv rate 10%, muon phat hien 20%+:
=> 7,200 visit total, 500/ngay → 14 ngay (kha thi).
| Traffic/ngay | Conv rate | Thoi gian can | Co nen test? |
|---|---|---|---|
| < 100 visit | Bat ky | 2+ thang | Khong — traffic thap |
| 100-500 | 2-5% | 3-6 tuan | Co, nhung kien nhan |
| 500-2K | 2-5% | 2-3 tuan | Co — ly tuong |
| 2K+ | Bat ky | 1-2 tuan | Co — nhanh |
Neu traffic thap (< 100/ngay) → khong test, thay vao do tap trung tang traffic truoc.
Tac dong cao nhat. 80% nguoi doc headline, 20% doc body → headline thay doi toi uu = bien nho nhat.
Idea:
Do thay doi duoc de test. Thuong tang 5-25%.
Test:
Test:
Test:
Test:
Test:
Test:
Test:
Khong test theo hung. Chon bien theo tac dong truoc, do de sau.
| Bien | Tac dong len ket qua | Do kho thuc hien | Uu tien | Metric chinh |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Creative — hook 0-3s | Rat cao (quyet dinh CTR va CPM) | De — chi doi 3 giay dau | 1 | Hook rate, CTR |
| Audience / tep | Cao (ai nhin thay ads) | De — doi setting | 2 | CPM, CPL |
| Offer / CTA | Rat cao (ho nhan duoc gi) | Trung binh — can quyet dinh kinh doanh | 3 | CVR, CPL |
| Landing page | Cao (trai nghiem sau click) | Kho — can dev/design | 4 | CVR, bounce |
| Ad copy (than bai) | Trung binh | De | 5 | CTR, CVR |
| Mau sac / font / chi tiet nho | Thap | De | 6 | — |
Quy tac: het bien uu tien 1 roi moi xuong 2. Dung nhay thang vao test mau nut khi hook chua bao gio duoc test.
| Vong | Test gi | Cach lam | Metric doc |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hook 0-3s | 3-5 hook khac nhau, giu nguyen than bai va CTA — Pain vs To mo vs Social proof | Hook rate |
| 2 | Format | Video doc vs Anh tinh vs Carousel | CTR, CPM, CPL |
| 3 | Goc nhin | Loi ich vs Van de vs Bien doi (before-after) | CTR, CVR |
| 4 | Do dai | 15s vs 30s vs 60s | Watch rate, CTR, CPL |
| Test | Phuong an A | Phuong an B |
|---|---|---|
| Broad vs Interest | Tep rong (de he thong tu tim) | Interest cu the |
| Interest A vs B | [Nhom so thich 1] | [Nhom so thich 2] |
| Do tuoi | 25-34 | 35-44 |
| Lookalike | 1% LAL | 3% LAL |
| Vi tri hien thi | Tu dong | Chi Feed |
| Hang muc | Nguong thuc dung |
|---|---|
| % ngan sach danh cho testing | 30% tong ngan sach (Testing 30% · Scale 50% · Retarget 15% · Lookalike 5%) |
| Ngan sach toi thieu | Du de moi bien the ra it nhat 1 conversion/ngay — duoi muc nay test khong bao gio ket luan duoc |
| Thoi gian toi thieu | 7 ngay tron (khong 3 ngay, khong 10 ngay le tuan) |
| Sample toi thieu — test ads tren nen tang | 50 conversion/bien the (hoac 1,000 click neu test CTR) |
| Sample ly tuong — test landing page | 100 conversion/bien the, hoac tinh theo cong thuc o tren |
| Dung som | Chi dung truoc han khi 1 bien the CPL > 2x target sau 3 ngay — dung bien the do, khong dung ca test |
Hai nguong sample khac nhau la co chu y: 50 la nguong thuc dung cho test ads (nen tang chay lien tuc, con nhieu vong test phia sau), 100 la nguong ly tuong khi test landing page (test 1 lan, sua xong kho lam lai).
| Ket qua | Quyet dinh | Buoc tiep |
|---|---|---|
| Winner ro (>= 15%, du data, p < 0.05) | Scale winner, luu tru loser | 55-scaling-ads |
| Chenh lech < 15% | Hoa — giu control, chuyen sang test bien khac | Quay lai ma tran uu tien |
| Cac metric mau thuan nhau (VD: CTR B cao hon nhung CPL A tot hon) | Theo metric chinh da chot tu dau, khong doi metric giua chung | — |
| Chua du sample khi het thoi gian | Keo dai them 3-7 ngay, hoac ket luan "khong du du lieu" va ghi vao log | — |
| Ca 2 bien the deu te hon baseline | Van de khong nam o bien dang test | 21-audit-ads-performance |
Winner hom nay = baseline de test tiep. Khong co diem dung — moi vong test lay winner cu lam control moi.
Bang nay quan trong khong kem ket qua tung test. Sau 6-12 thang, pattern trong log cho biet loai bien nao thuc su tao ra khac biet o nganh cua minh.
| # | Ngay bat dau | Ngay ket thuc | Bien test | Control (A) | Variant (B) | Metric chinh | Ket qua | p-value | Uplift | Hanh dong | Bai hoc |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Winner A / Winner B / Hoa | Scale / Luu tru / Test lai | |||||||||
| 2 |
| Tool | Phu hop | Chi phi |
|---|---|---|
| Meta Ads A/B test built-in | Test ads (creative/audience/placement) | Free |
| TikTok Ads Split test | Test TikTok ads | Free |
| Google Optimize (deprecated) | Da ngung — dung thay the: VWO, Convert.com | Tu $199/thang |
| PostHog | Test product features, landing | Free tier OK |
| Unbounce / Instapage | Landing page built-in A/B | $90+/thang |
| Manual (split URL) | Don gian, 50/50 URL redirect | Free |
1. Tao 2 phien ban landing page: /page-a va /page-b
2. Split traffic 50/50:
- Qua Meta Ads: 2 ad set cung audience, khac link dich
- Qua Google Ads: 2 ad cung traffic, khac link
- Qua organic: dung URL rewrite (rare)
3. Tracking conversion rieng tung page:
- Meta Pixel: event "Lead" voi custom parameter "page_version" = A/B
- GA4: UTM campaign=test-header, utm_content=a/b
4. Sau 14 ngay + du sample, export dataDung calculator online: https://www.evanmiller.org/ab-testing/chi-squared.html
Input:
Output:
| p-value | Uplift | Ket luan |
|---|---|---|
| < 0.05 | > 5% | B thang — implement B |
| < 0.05 | < 5% | Significant nhung nho — can nhac cost |
| 0.05-0.10 | > 10% | Ket qua borderline — keo dai test |
| > 0.10 | Bat ky | Khong significant — giu A hoac test tiep |
# A/B Test: [Ten test]
Ngay tao: [YYYY-MM-DD]
Chu so huu: [Ten nguoi]
## 1. Gia thuyet
"Neu [thay doi X], [metric Y] se tang [Z%]"
## 2. Bien test
- Variant A (Control): [Mo ta hien tai]
- Variant B (Challenger): [Mo ta thay doi]
- Chi thay doi: [1 thing]
## 3. Metric
- Primary: [VD: Conversion rate]
- Secondary: [VD: Bounce rate, Time on page]
## 4. Sample size & Duration
- Baseline: [p = %]
- MDE: [% change muon phat hien]
- Sample/variant: [so]
- Traffic/ngay: [so]
- Thoi gian can: [so ngay]
## 5. Setup
- Tool: [Ten]
- URL A: [...]
- URL B: [...]
- Tracking: [Meta Pixel / GA4 / PostHog events]
- Split: 50/50 (hoac khac ghi ro)
## 6. Timeline
- Start: [ngay]
- End: [ngay]
- Review: [ngay]
## 7. Ket qua (dien sau khi ket thuc)
| Variant | Visitors | Conversions | Rate | Uplift vs A |
|---------|----------|-------------|------|-------------|
| A | | | | — |
| B | | | | +X% |
p-value: [x]
Significant (p<0.05): [Yes/No]
## 8. Ket luan
[B thang / A thang / Khong significant]
## 9. Hanh dong
[Implement / Test tiep / Rollback]
## 10. Bai hoc
[Dieu hoc duoc → ap dung cho test sau]~30 seconds. Free. No account. Every finding cites a rule and a line of evidence.