est-workflow — independently scanned and version-tracked by SaferSkills.
SaferSkills independently audited est-workflow (Agent Skill) and scored it 100/100 (green). The audit ran 55 deterministic rules across Security, Supply Chain, Maintenance, Transparency, and Community; it found 0 high-severity and 0 lower-severity findings. The full rule-by-rule trace and per-finding evidence are below. Free, methodology-open.
Findings & checks · 0 flagged
Every scanned point with the score it earned and what moved between them.
First recorded scan — no prior version to compare against.
The primary manifest — the file an agent reads to learn what this artifact does.
The orchestrator for an ES&T submission. Figure out the stage and the article type, then send the user to the matching skill. ES&T is a multidisciplinary environmental science and engineering journal — the router's first job is to make sure the paper carries clear environmental significance, not just a clean lab result.
est-revision-and-rebuttal)| Situation | Type | Route to |
|---|---|---|
| Full original study | Research Article (~7,000 words; 待核实) | normal pipeline below |
| Urgent, high-impact result, short | ES&T Letters (Letter ≤3,000 words; separate journal) | tighten scope; est-submission |
| Comprehensive synthesis of a field | Critical Review (~10,000 words; 待核实) | est-literature-positioning + est-writing-style |
| Forward-looking opinion/synthesis | Perspective (~4,000 words; 待核实) | est-literature-positioning |
| Magazine-style accessible piece | Feature (~5,000 words; 待核实) | est-writing-style |
| Science–policy interface analysis | Policy Analysis (~7,000 words; 待核实) | est-topic-selection + est-writing-style |
Word caps are volatile and figures/tables may count as word-equivalents — confirm on the live guidelines page (see 待核实 in resources/official-source-map.md).Idea / environmental significance? → est-topic-selection
Where does it sit in the field? → est-literature-positioning
Is the study design defensible? → est-study-design
Are the analyses + QA/QC sound? → est-data-analysis
Are the exhibits + TOC art clear? → est-figures-and-tables
SI, data deposit, reproducibility? → est-reporting-and-reproducibility
Does it read in ACS style? → est-writing-style
Cover letter to the editor? → est-cover-letter
How will it be judged? → est-review-process
Ready to submit? → est-submission
Got a decision / revision? → est-revision-and-rebuttaltopic-selection → literature-positioning → study-design → data-analysis → figures-and-tables → reporting-and-reproducibility → writing-style → cover-letter → review-process → submission → revision-and-rebuttal
Iterate: most papers loop design ↔ analysis ↔ QA/QC several times before writing-style.
When a user arrives mid-stream with a specific complaint, route by symptom rather than walking the whole pipeline. Each symptom carries the ES&T-specific failure mode it signals:
| User says | Underlying ES&T risk | Route to |
|---|---|---|
| "Is this significant enough?" | desk-decline on significance | est-topic-selection |
| "A reviewer said it's not novel" | incremental-occurrence framing | est-literature-positioning |
| "Reviewer wants more controls/QA-QC" | analytical-rigor gap | est-study-design, est-data-analysis |
| "Mass balance doesn't close" | unaccounted-fraction objection | est-data-analysis |
| "Do I need a TOC graphic?" | incomplete-submission gate | est-figures-and-tables |
| "Where do I deposit the data?" | data-availability mandate | est-reporting-and-reproducibility |
| "Got a major revision" | response-letter strategy | est-revision-and-rebuttal |
A user starts: "I have river PFAS data showing a precursor converting to PFHxA — where do I begin?" The router's pass (illustrative):
est-topic-selection: reframe from occurrence to "surveys under-countpersistent burden," confirming Research-Article fit.
est-literature-positioning: engage the fate, analytical, and tox literatures sonovelty is mechanistic, not "another dataset."
est-study-design ↔ est-data-analysis: lock the abiotic control, massbalance, and QA/QC; handle the censored values with ROS.
est-figures-and-tables, est-reporting-and-reproducibility: build a conceptTOC graphic and deposit data/spectra/code.
est-writing-style → est-cover-letter → est-submission.The router's standing job: surface the environmental-significance and QA/QC gates early, because those are what the desk editor and the ~three reviewers weigh first.
【Stage】idea / positioning / design / analysis / exhibits / reproducibility / writing / cover-letter / review / submit / revise
【Type】Research Article / Critical Review / Feature / Perspective / Policy Analysis / ES&T Letters
【Route to】est-<skill>
【Why】one line
【Then】the next skill after that../../resources/external_tools.md — environmental data, instruments, and software by sub-area../../resources/official-source-map.md — official ES&T URLs behind every fact in this pack~30 seconds. Free. No account. Every finding cites a rule and a line of evidence.